SF dancer in NYC – 5 nights of salsa reviews

San Francisco dancer in NYC – 5 nights of salsa reviews

Note: This is transferred directly from DanceForums. A SalsaForum member suggested I repost it here. I am aware that there is some membership overlap. Hope this helps those who only visit SalsaForms.

Thanks to DF members for recommending clubs.

These reviews apply to my week in NYC on September 21-28. Five nights straight is definitely a record for me. This is not exactly a statistical sampling but I think the experience tells me a little about the difference between the SF and NYC salsa scenes. Here is a summary of the clubs for other visitors to the city.

Monday – Taj (48 W 21st St). This is a nice dark intimate bar. The skill level of the dancers was pretty good. A few criticisms though . . . The dance floor was a little too slick for the leather soled dance shoes I was wearing so I had to be pretty careful. The drinks are way too expensive. The music is a tad too loud but fortunately I brought my earplugs. I got in several dances and I generally had a good time. I probably wouldn’t go back if there is an alternative. Some DF members mentioned Session 73 for Monday’s.

Tuesday – Sidebar (120 East 15th St.) I got to Sidebar at 9pm and the dancing was already going strong. The bar is an oval and there is room to dance on both sides of the bar though the all the dancing was only on one side while I was there making for a fairly small dance space. It is well lit and there is a mezzanine where you can sit to watch the action. The skill level of the dancers is very high. Everyone was really friendly and I got a lot of dancing in. This place is basically fantastic and I would be here every Tuesday if I lived in NYC.

Wednesday – LQ (511 Lexington Avenue) Don’t go here . . . enough said . . .

Thursday – Club Cache (221 W 46th St) This place is a hidden gem and I do mean hidden. It was a block from my hotel and I thought I would just check the location earlier in the evening. All I saw was an Italian restaurant. It turns out that at about 9:30 a sign goes up over a door that normally says “Tony and Tina’s Wedding” and “voila” you have Club Cache. Down some steep stairs and there is a nice dance/performance space. There was a short on-2 beginners lesson by the bar. The skill level of the dancers was very high and I recognized some of the dancers from Sidebar. Once again I had a fantastic time here and would highly recommend this club. It starts a little late. I was there from 10pm – 1:30pm.

Friday – Abakua (412 Eighth Avenue) This is an elegant dance studio on a fourth floor, one side of which is Club 412. It opens at 9pm but few people show up before 10:30. It is a social so I socialized with the few people who were there and got in some dancing. They were mostly beginners. At 10:30 the really experienced dancers showed up. This club is where I finally met my match with the NYC salsa scene. The music was great but it was also very challenging for my level of musicality which is pretty weak on my part. I couldn’t really keep up. I did enjoy watching for a while. I would recommend this club to highly skilled dancers. This club gives me something to aspire too.

So here are the differences between the SF and NYC salsa scenes that I saw during my 5 nights of salsa:

* It is a very young crowd. There is more age diversity or lets say a larger age range in San Francisco.
* The skill level of the NYC clubs is very high. There were almost no beginners and intermediates. I would rate myself as an intermediate. I try to dance with advanced dancers whenever I can because how else will I get from here to there? NYC was fun but a bit intimidating.
* All the music was DJ music this past week. No live music which SF has regularly Tuesday – Saturday. I would assume that NYC has live music somewhere sometime.
* The places I went to in NYC were relatively small crowds relative to the crowds in SF but I realize that crowd size can be highly variable.
* I wasn’t going out for the lessons. The one lesson at Cache was about 30 minutes of the basics. Club lessons in the Bay Area are a much bigger thing. They go on for about an hour. There are beginner and intermediate level lessons. They can sometimes get pretty large attendance. There can easily be 40-50 couples at Allegro or Cocomo for lessons in SF


Basically, I had a great time and look forward to returning sometime. Thanks. I wouldn’t have been able to have this good a time without DF member recommendations!
 
:) hey it was nice to read about your experience of the NY salsa scene. :) you pretty much hit the right places too, gives us a shout the next time you come to NY.
 
* It is a very young crowd. There is more age diversity or lets say a larger age range in San Francisco.
* The skill level of the NYC clubs is very high. There were almost no beginners and intermediates. I would rate myself as an intermediate. I try to dance with advanced dancers whenever I can because how else will I get from here to there? NYC was fun but a bit intimidating.

* All the music was DJ music this past week. No live music which SF has regularly Tuesday – Saturday. I would assume that NYC has live music somewhere sometime.
* The places I went to in NYC were relatively small crowds relative to the crowds in SF but I realize that crowd size can be highly variable.
* I wasn’t going out for the lessons. The one lesson at Cache was about 30 minutes of the basics. Club lessons in the Bay Area are a much bigger thing. They go on for about an hour. There are beginner and intermediate level lessons. They can sometimes get pretty large attendance. There can easily be 40-50 couples at Allegro or Cocomo for lessons in SF

it's always refreshing to hear the opinions of outsiders and get their perspective. There's a bit of a feedback loop in all of this, because the dancers are better, they usually do things that require more...athleticism...and it's more likely that you'll get younger people trying it. At least that's my theory, although I could easily put holes in that argument. In contrast, I find the tango scene to be a little older, and because of the contrast I feel a bit uncomfortable

As far as intimidating...yeah I feel you on that one. I'm constantly dealing with that
 
* It is a very young crowd. There is more age diversity or lets say a larger age range in San Francisco.
* The skill level of the NYC clubs is very high. There were almost no beginners and intermediates. I would rate myself as an intermediate. I try to dance with advanced dancers whenever I can because how else will I get from here to there? NYC was fun but a bit intimidating.

I am also from the Bay and visited NYC for the first time, I was at Jimmy Anton's (birthday) social and another one (Choco's?) at the 54th street.

After regularly visiting the AFINKAO socials and arriving from the Toronto salsa congress, the level of dancing did not seem so amazingly high, maybe the ratio of good dancers was higher than here, but not the absolute number. I don't even consider myself intermediate, but I had a lot of compliments from the women, although some of them looked at me, as if I came from outer space....

I did not find the crowd especially young. Even in Baltimore, the average age seemed to be lower, but compared to Europe (esp. Hungary) every place in the States looks quite diverse.
 
Those of you from NYC . . . what's the deal with live music? I didn't get to hear any there. It's a regular thing in the Bay Area. Did I just not go to the right places? or at the right time?

I already have plans to be back in NYC Fall of 2009 . . .
 
Those of you from NYC . . . what's the deal with live music? I didn't get to hear any there. It's a regular thing in the Bay Area. Did I just not go to the right places? or at the right time?

I already have plans to be back in NYC Fall of 2009 . . .


most dancers I know always complain about the pitfalls of dancing to live music, Crowded dance floor(by non dancers) and super long songs.

Most of the well attended salsa socials in NY, never have live salsa, unless it is an especial occasion. To get live music, you will have to go to clubs,where dancing is not the greatest Session 73, LQ, SOB, Thaj.
 
Piel is spot on. I personally like DJ sets , because the songs they choose aren't just the hits of one artists, but they are choosen because of how danceable they are and how many breaks etc. Also as someone who collects albums, I like to hear new stuff that I wouldn't have otherwise heard and makes me go to the DJ and inquire.

There are plenty of live sets in NYC, but you have to know where to go. They are less attended spots and while I know of them, I never go.
 
I know what you are getting at with the difference between DJ music and live music. We get a bit of both. DJ music for the first 45-60 minutes followed by live music. We are pretty lucky in the Bay Area. We have some very good local salsa bands. Occasionally we get bands from outside the Bay Area. In LA the bands at Mama Juana's are simply fantastic.

If the club and DJ are focusing on songs with good breaks then DJ music is obviously the way to go.
 
Must......................Get.....................to..........................New............................York!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Thanks for the recap, makes me even more keen :) :) :)

Hurray, now for the Aus dollar and my dancing to improve (which will improve first, my dancing or the dollar he he) and then Hello New York!!!!!!!!

Hello NY Salsa forums members :)

Hurray!
 
Hey SalsaMarty,

I just recently came back from NYC this past weekend from the Abakua Frankie Martinez Social and it was awesome. Plenty of well experienced dancers. Instead of being intimidated, i went ahead and asked them for a dance :), it was awesome! I'm from the DC/MD area, so NYC was a little spark of excitement for me. What you had said about having a group of highly skilled dancers is dead on. I would also recommend this social for the highly experienced dancers. People are really friendly also. Exchanged some e-mails and phone numbers ;).

check out my videos from this social

youtube.com/bolivicano
 
Mmm.... I think there should be some rule that whenever anyone is visiting NYC from SF.....They have to check in with the NYC residents on the forum.....!!! People please help me achieve my 2009 resolution of dancing with as many people from SF.

Anyhow, If you guys want live music, there are a couple of CUTE places in Brooklyn that I have encountered by mere accident, the bands are fun, play a variety of songs and styles and you can still dance(but do not expect too much though)
 
hey bolivicano -

Oh . . . I danced at Abakua with some of the good dancers. I just crashed and burned on the musical breaks. I felt like I was torturing my partners so I finally called it a night. However, the experience has motivated me to work on my musicality between now and when I return next fall.
 
Mmm.... I think there should be some rule that whenever anyone is visiting NYC from SF.....They have to check in with the NYC residents on the forum.....!!! People please help me achieve my 2009 resolution of dancing with as many people from SF.

Anyhow, If you guys want live music, there are a couple of CUTE places in Brooklyn that I have encountered by mere accident, the bands are fun, play a variety of songs and styles and you can still dance(but do not expect too much though)
I second that...although I still have yet to dance with all the NYC Sfers :P
 
-salsamarty,

i know what u mean. what helps is really listening to the music and knowing the structure of the songs. just listen to some more salsa and more mambos/guaguancos and u'll start gettin the hang of it. yea, i loved that social! haha
 
Back
Top