Jag75
Son Montuno
The way I was taught is...EXACTLY the way Oliver does it. In particular pay attention to the direction his body faces, not just the steps. Oliver does do more of an ankle flick (whatever) into the 7, but I think that's stylistic and is more unique to what he's used to with Luda.
So I'll go step by step on2.
1 - prepare for the crossbody
2 - prepare for the inside turn
3 - turn on 3 and perpare to insert arm deep across her back
4 - move momentum forward before step
5 - step with the right foot, near and to the right of her pivot point for the inside turn. Your foot can point in different directions depending on lead and follow, however the momentum built up in 3 and 4, should already start to create some rotational force across the balls of your feet. Arm should already have a hold on her back, usually under her shoulder blades.
6 - you should be sideways, with your shoulders inline, parallel with the slot. The 6 step is light, witht the left foot and the closer to the axis it is ,the better. The rotational force built in previous steps should continue and no real weight is placed on 6 as much as it can be used to continue to generate the force with pivoting with the 6. This step is light as far as I can tell. (relative to sweavo's method I think in his method he puts weight on his left, shifts weight back to the left, before continuing the launch into the 7 forcing momentum from the hips, into the balls of the feet).
7 - pivot on the right foot and finish with a majority of the rotational force, ending with your back on the other side of the slot and still in parallel with the slot line.
while i don't disagree that the timing conventions are tougher to judge on Oliver's video. I'll break down what I see in both videos.
Oliver: as of 3:10 he basically does what I'm saying above. What's scary is how he barely travels to get where he needs to be. I think he might shift his weight on his right foot from the ball to his heel as he rotates, allowing him to move out of the way for the cross body. Once he steps on 5 (the major traveling step used to build momentum), he's pretty much done taking major steps, and everything else is pivot until 1.
MamboSF: The placing of the hand is on her left shoulder, which is a major distinction between the two methods. Let's forward to 2:40 on the above video, where his back is to you and you can see from the light under his foot when and how he steps (he does the steps slightly differently between when he teachs it and it's actually easier to see when he's fully in motion.
5 - he steps in place
5n - he places his hand behind her left shoulder (not deep across the back)
6 - far forward with the left foot and pointing with the slot (shoulders perpendicular to the slot line), this is the the major traveling step used to build momentum
7 - steps behind her and is swiveling on his 6, and this is what creates the whip motion. With some strength, I bet this is fun.
Thinking about how the mechanics would feel, it might be nice to do it mambosf's way, but it is far different from Oliver's method. I'm not saying one is better than the other, just that they're different. I haven't looked at Juan's footwork and weight exchange.
Can we have someone else look these up and confirm? This is my understanding of things. Please correct me if I'm being retarded.
EDIT: the second Juan video at 34 seconds: Juan's major traveling step is his right foot, not his left. Juan's method is the same as Oliver's, although it looks like he uses less rotational force, but is deeper across the back than MamboSF although not as deep as Oliver which is stylistic.
Great post! That's exactly how I learned it through doing a private with Becky Lee from Salsa Suave in Sydney - the breakdown being exactly the same count-for-count. It felt really odd at first but once you get used to doing it correctly it's amazing how natural it ends up feeling.
It looks simple but is in fact one of the harder things to master in salsa.
My advice is don't try to replicate it but instead get taught correctly how to do it - everything from footwork, to applying the right kind of pressure to the right part of the follow's back, timing, and body position.